The Sacred and the Sublime: Evolution of Oil Painting and Sculpture in New Mexico (1835-1885)
by Gemini 2.5, June 6, 2025
I. Introduction: New Mexico's Artistic Crucible (1835-1885)
The period from 1835 to 1885 marked a profound and transformative era for New Mexico, shifting its identity from a remote northern frontier of independent Mexico to a U.S. territory following the Mexican-American War and the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo in 1848. This geopolitical transition ushered in significant changes, including an influx of American settlers, new laws, and shifts in land ownership, fundamentally altering the region's demographic, economic, and political landscape. Despite becoming a U.S. territory in 1850, New Mexico faced persistent challenges, including ongoing conflicts with Native American tribes, economic difficulties, and a prolonged struggle for statehood that would not be achieved until 1912. The Civil War (1861) and Indian Wars (until 1885) further complicated the social fabric, though New Mexicans often felt little direct stake in the national conflict.
Anglo-Americans, though initially small in number, gained considerable influence through the establishment of merchants, military presence (such as Fort Union in 1851 and Fort Stanton in 1855), and the rise of lawyers, a shift noted by figures like Padre Antonio Jose Martinez of Taos. This dynamic fostered a complex interplay of cultural tension and adaptation. The Hispanic majority often favored statehood to elect native officials, while the Anglo minority found advantage in the territorial system. Amidst these profound external pressures and changes in governance, the New Mexican people, accustomed to living by "luck and hope," demonstrated remarkable resilience and a firm character. This inherent cultural fortitude found a powerful outlet in artistic expression, which served as a vital vehicle for maintaining cultural and spiritual continuity. The idealized figures of saints, embodying virtues, offered spiritual comfort and moral guidance, reinforcing positive community values when external societal structures were shifting and often hostile. This meant the art was not merely reflective of culture but actively constitutive of it, providing a stable spiritual and moral compass.
(above: Santo from the exhibit Santos and Retablos)
New Mexico's artistic landscape during this time was thus a rich "palimpsest of cultures layered atop one another," profoundly shaped by indigenous, Spanish, Mexican, and emerging Anglo influences. The region's relative isolation, particularly before the arrival of the transcontinental train in 1879, fostered a distinct artistic identity rooted in necessity and local resources. The dominant art forms were deeply religious, primarily the santero tradition, which included painted wood panels (retablos) and carved wooden sculptures (bultos). True oil painting on canvas was notably rare due to the difficulty of obtaining the medium in frontier conditions. This geographical remoteness and the scarcity of conventional art supplies compelled local artisans to innovate and adapt with indigenous resources. This forced self-reliance, coupled with the absence of formal European academic training, forged a unique, distinctively New Mexican aesthetic. This style, while perhaps considered "naive" by external academic standards, was profoundly effective for its devotional purpose, allowing for a direct, emotionally resonant connection with the faithful and emphasizing spiritual truth and accessibility over technical perfection or illusionism.
Within this complex historical context, the art of New Mexico, through both its indigenous-influenced idealism and emerging Anglo-American realism, consistently emphasized beauty, positive virtues, and the lifting of people's spirits. It served not merely as decoration but as a vital cultural anchor, a source of solace, and a means of preserving identity amidst profound change.
II. The Enduring Spirit: Santero Art and its Devotional Power
A. Foundations of Faith: The Santero Tradition
The santero tradition, the creation of sacred images known as santos, formed the artistic bedrock of New Mexican expression throughout this period. These images, encompassing two-dimensional retablos (paintings on wood panels) and three-dimensional bultos (carved wooden sculptures), were deeply woven into the spiritual fabric of Hispanic New Mexican communities. In a land with "very few priests," santos served as essential devotional figures, providing a vital "plug-in to the divine" and a direct "link heaven and earth" for the faithful.
The materials used by santeros were predominantly local and natural, a testament to the ingenuity born of New Mexico's isolation and resourcefulness. Retablos were typically painted on hand-hewn pine boards, prepared with gesso made from native gypsum. Pigments were meticulously derived from local minerals and vegetable dyes, such as yellows and oranges from iron oxides, blue from indigo, and reds from cochineal, applied with simple brushes fashioned from feathers or yucca. Bultos were carved from readily available cottonwood or pine, then gessoed and painted. A protective pinesap varnish often sealed the finished works. This reliance on indigenous and locally sourced materials, rather than hindering artistic development, fostered a unique aesthetic, making the art uniquely suited to its purpose of spiritual uplift in a frontier environment.
These santos were created for a variety of contexts, including churches, home altars, and the private devotional chapter houses of lay brotherhoods, most notably the Penitentes. They were instrumental in promoting and teaching the Catholic religion, embodying positive virtues, and offering spiritual solace and a sense of control in a perilous environment. The art provided a tangible source of comfort and guidance in daily life, addressing concerns from bountiful harvests to protection against witchcraft.
B. Realism and Idealism in Santero Art
New Mexican santero art diverged significantly from the academic traditions prevalent in central Mexico or Europe. It was often characterized by a "stylized realism" or a "naive" quality , frequently simplifying and flattening figures to a "quasi-abstract" appearance. This aesthetic prioritized spiritual meaning and devotional function over illusionistic accuracy. The stylistic evolution towards simplified and flattened forms, moving away from 18th-century illusionism, suggests a deliberate artistic choice where the spiritual message and devotional function took precedence over academic realism. This made the art more universally accessible and emotionally resonant for the community, directly contributing to the lifting of people's spirits.
The idealism inherent in santero art stemmed directly from its focus on the essence of the divine and virtuous. Figures were rendered with "gracefully simple expression" , emphasizing their spiritual power and accessibility rather than anatomical precision. This allowed the art to resonate deeply with a largely illiterate populace, who recognized saints by their symbolic attributes and connected with their spiritual purpose. The "realism" in santero art was not concerned with mimetic accuracy (photographic verisimilitude) but rather with iconographic realism. It focused on conveying the recognizable essence of a sacred figure through symbolic attributes and a humanized, albeit simplified, form, making it relatable to the local community. The "idealism," conversely, centered on the spiritual ideal embodied by the saint -- their virtues, their intercessory power, and their capacity to offer spiritual comfort and hope. This unique blend allowed the art to effectively convey beauty, positive virtues, and the lifting of people's spirits within its specific cultural and material constraints.
A significant aspect of this period was the "indigenization" of Catholic iconography. Beginning in the 1830s, the art began to move "away from that Baroque Mexican feel to a straight-up Indigenous idea of perspective and landscape and animation". This blending of Catholic and Native traditions, evident in the use of water-based paints similar to those employed by Pueblo Indians and the incorporation of Pueblo symbols, created a uniquely New Mexican aesthetic. This stylistic shift made the imported faith feel authentically rooted in the land and its existing cultures, thereby enhancing its power to uplift spirits and reinforce a shared identity.
However, the increasing connectivity brought by trade routes also presented a challenge to this traditional art form. The Santa Fe Trail, a commercial highway linking New Mexico to the eastern United States, brought not only new materials like tin but also "inexpensive framed prints of holy figures" and "mass-produced plaster statues from Europe". This influx of cheaper, mass-produced alternatives directly competed with and "forced the santeros out of business" , leading to a decline in the traditional santero profession "well before the turn of this century". This economic shift, coupled with the deletion of Article X regarding land grants in the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, which led to "Mexican land loss" and Anglo economic dominance, directly impacted the ability of Hispanic communities to commission or purchase santos, contributing to the art form's eventual decline.
(above: Santo from the exhibit Santos and Retablos from the exhibit Santos and Retablos)
C. Masters of Devotion: Critically Acclaimed Santeros
The period from 1835 to 1885 saw the continued work of several influential santeros who shaped the devotional art landscape of New Mexico:
José Rafael Aragón (c. 1796-1862): Widely considered the "premier santero of his time" , Aragón was exceptionally prolific and versatile, creating both retablos and bultos for churches and private clients throughout the Santa Cruz Valley and Taos area. Active from before 1820, he moved to Quemado (later Córdova) around 1835, where he carved and painted the main altar of the Church of San Antonio, significantly expanding his reputation.His distinct style featured "creative decorative motifs, color contrasts, elongated and graceful proportions, delicate features and a distinctive bump on the nose" for his sculptural figures. A conservator noted that Aragón "was not at all influenced by formal Spanish painting" and "didn't give a hoot about what was going on in the academies". His ability to render figures "strongly and sensitively" with "fine details and gracefully simple expression" on figures like the Virgin Mary exemplifies how santeros conveyed profound spiritual beauty without academic pretense. This approach made his sacred images deeply relatable and spiritually uplifting for his community. · ·
(above: José Rafael Aragón, Our Lady of Mount Carmel (Nuestra Señora del Carmen), 9.3 x 7.2 inches, Barnes Foundation. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons*)
(above: José Rafael Aragón: Español: Nuestra Señora de Guadeloupe English: Our Lady of Guadeloupe, c. 1818-1864, pine wood, gesso and water-based paints, 13 5/8 x 11 5/8 inches, Brooklyn Museum, Museum Expedition 1911, Museum Collection Fund, 11.694.9072. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons*)
Molleno (active c. 1800-c. 1850): Working primarily in the Chimayó area, Molleno's prolific artistic period firmly places him within the early part of this timeframe. He is known for his stylistic evolution from "somewhat realistic figures to more simplified, abstract figures". His palette often featured bold bright reds, yellows, blacks, and blues, sometimes limited to just two colors, and he employed distinctive brushwork with "large strokes with feathered detail". This progression towards abstraction in his retablos and bultos reflects a heightened spiritual idealism, where the spiritual message transcended strict mimesis, directly serving the devotional needs of the community. His original approach, not meticulously following standard prototypes, allowed him to create impactful works like the massive altar screens for the church of San Francisco de Asis at Ranchos de Taos.
Pedro Antonio Fresquís (1749-1831): Although his primary active period concluded before 1835, Fresquís is critically acclaimed as the "first native-born New Mexican santero" , and his foundational style profoundly influenced the santero tradition that flourished in the specified period. His flat paintings, characterized by simple outlines, long narrow noses, and decorative borders often scratched through wet paint, established a distinctive folk art aesthetic. His works, such as multiple depictions of Our Lady of Guadalupe, provided essential devotional images that uplifted spirits and reinforced faith among the populace. His unique approach, devoid of direct antecedents in New Spain, set a precedent for the localized and spiritually focused art of New Mexico. ·
Juan Miguel Herrera (1835-1905): Born at the very beginning of the specified period, Herrera was active from approximately 1870 to 1895, primarily sculpting Penitente figures for moradas (religious meeting houses) in the Taos area. His bultos, such as Jesus Nazareno (c. 1860), were fashioned using tempera and enamel, often featuring "raised eyebrows and pronounced upper eyelids," and Christ figures with "open mouths, sometimes with teeth showing with beards being thickly carved and incised". These stylistic choices imbued his figures with an intense emotional and spiritual realism, reflecting the Penitente brotherhood's deep commitment to imitating Christ's suffering as a path to holiness and spiritual uplift. The Penitente brotherhood, which emerged to fill the void left by a scarcity of clergy, sought to "imitate Christ's suffering and live lives of holiness". Herrera's art, while depicting suffering, ultimately aimed to inspire virtue, penance, and a hopeful path to salvation, thus directly fulfilling the query's criteria of emphasizing positive virtues and lifting people's spirits through a deeply felt, rather than merely beautiful, realism. ·
José Benito Ortega (1858-1941): As arguably the most prolific of the "pre-revival" santeros, Ortega was active from the 1870s to the early 1900s, working in remote villages near Mora. Despite facing significant competition from mass-produced plaster statues imported by the clergy, Ortega steadfastly produced traditional images for Penitente moradas, churches, chapels, and private use. His figures, often crafted from humble materials like scrap wood and rags, are noted for their "crude carving of hands and feet" contrasted with "sensitive, individual facial features". His Our Father Jesus of Nazareth (ca. 1885), a relatively large figure used in Holy Week processions, powerfully conveys the suffering of Christ, ultimately serving to inspire virtue and spiritual reflection within the community. His dedication to traditional forms amidst challenging circumstances underscores the profound spiritual need his art fulfilled.
III. New Perspectives: Anglo-American Artists and the Documented Landscape
A. The Arrival of New Visions: Landscape and Life
Towards the latter part of the 1835-1885 period, particularly with the arrival of the transcontinental train in 1879, New Mexico experienced a "culture rush". This influx brought European-American artists and anthropologists who were eager to document the unique Southwestern landscape and its diverse cultures, often for publications like Harper's Weekly and Scribners. This marked a shift in artistic purpose, moving towards ethnographic studies and romantic or nostalgic portrayals of Native American and Hispanic daily life and rituals.
While the major Taos and Santa Fe art colonies, known for their landscape and figure painting in oil, largely flourished after 1885, the seeds of this artistic movement were sown in the final years of the specified period. The introduction and growing presence of oil painting on canvas, often with a more academic or realistic approach, began to contrast with the local santero tradition's focus on painted wood panels. This external interest, while leading to documentation, also carried the potential for commodification, where art was sometimes used to advertise the "exotic Southwestern landscape" and its people, occasionally resulting in stereotypical images.
B. Documenting the Era: Early Anglo-American Painters
Two notable Anglo-American artists began to engage with New Mexico's subjects within this timeframe, primarily through drawings, prints, and watercolors, representing an emerging form of realism:
Peter Moran (1841-1914): The younger brother of the acclaimed landscapist Thomas Moran, Peter Moran began producing a substantial body of paintings, drawings, and prints depicting New Mexican subjects from 1880 onwards. His works, such as the 1883 etching Harvest at San Juan Pueblo, captured scenes of Pueblo Indian life, including the herding of horses. Moran's efforts established him as the first artist to create a significant visual record of the region, contributing to a realistic portrayal of its inhabitants and environment. His documentation, while serving an external audience, offered glimpses into the daily lives and activities of the people, fostering a broader understanding and appreciation for their existence.
Thomas Moran (1837-1926): A renowned American painter celebrated for capturing the grandeur of Yellowstone and the Grand Canyon, Thomas Moran also made influential visits to New Mexico, particularly from 1881. His watercolor and graphite work, such as Española, New Mexico (1881), portrayed the distinctive flat-roofed adobe architecture and the expansive Rio Grande Valley. Though his New Mexico etchings were fewer in number than his brother's, his 1881 image of San Juan Pueblo further demonstrated his engagement with the region. Thomas Moran's works, while often romanticized, contributed to a realist depiction of the Southwestern landscape's majestic beauty, helping to create a mystique around the region that would attract future artists and visitors. His ability to convey the awe-inspiring natural environment could certainly be seen as lifting the spirits of those who viewed his art.
·
IV. Conclusion: A Legacy of Enduring Art
The period from 1835 to 1885 in New Mexico was a dynamic crucible for artistic evolution, characterized by a profound interplay between continuity and change. The deeply rooted santero tradition, with its focus on devotional retablos and bultos, remained the spiritual and artistic heart of Hispanic communities. These works, crafted from local materials with ingenious resourcefulness, embodied a unique "stylized realism" and profound spiritual idealism, serving as essential "plug-ins to the divine" and a source of comfort, guidance, and identity amidst a tumultuous historical transition. The art of santeros like José Rafael Aragón, Molleno, Pedro Antonio Fresquís, Juan Miguel Herrera, and José Benito Ortega consistently emphasized beauty through spiritual essence, promoted positive virtues through iconic representation, and lifted people's spirits by providing tangible connections to their faith and heritage. The stylistic shifts, including the increasing influence of indigenous aesthetics and the movement towards simplified, quasi-abstract forms, demonstrate an organic adaptation that prioritized spiritual function over academic norms.
Towards the close of this era, the arrival of the railroad in 1879 marked a new chapter, bringing increased external interest and the emergence of Anglo-American artists like Peter Moran and Thomas Moran. These artists, primarily through prints and watercolors, began to document the unique landscapes and cultures of New Mexico with a more conventional realist approach. While their work contributed to a broader understanding and appreciation of the region, it also foreshadowed the commodification of native arts and the eventual decline of the traditional santero profession due to competition from mass-produced religious items.
In synthesis, the art of New Mexico from 1835 to 1885 reveals a compelling narrative of resilience and adaptation. Whether through the deeply personal and spiritually charged creations of the santeros or the emerging documentary efforts of Anglo-American artists, the artistic output of this period consistently fulfilled its purpose: to emphasize beauty, reinforce positive virtues, and uplift the human spirit in a land undergoing profound transformation. This dual artistic evolution laid the groundwork for New Mexico's enduring and unique artistic identity, a legacy that continues to inspire and resonate today.
Also see The Canvas and the Carving: New Mexico Artistry, 1885-1945, Through Lenses of Beauty and Uplift is a 2025 article by Gemini AI which says: "This period stands as a testament to the transformative power of cultural fusion, where Indigenous, Hispanic, and Anglo influences intricately intertwined to forge a uniquely New Mexican artistic identity. Throughout this era, artists, driven by individual creative genius and a profound connection to their environment and communities, produced a body of work that continues to inspire and uplift. This collective artistic endeavor significantly contributed to the enduring cultural richness of the state, serving as a powerful reflection and shaper of identity. Across all artistic movements and individual artists, a strong sense of identity-whether cultural, spiritual, or regional -- emerges as a core theme. Santeros created art that embodied communal and ethnic identity. Artists of the Taos and Santa Fe colonies sought to capture a "distinctive view of the nation" and a profound "sense of place". Native artists like Allan Houser explicitly aimed to "give people a sense of self, so they could be better humans". Art in New Mexico during this period was not merely decorative; it was a powerful tool for defining, preserving, and asserting identity in a rapidly changing world. It helped communities and individuals navigate cultural shifts, express their values, and find beauty and strength in their heritage, thereby fulfilling the mandate of "lifting people's spirits" by affirming who they were and what they could become." Accessed 6/25
Note: Please don't rely on this AI-generated text for accuracy. It has been lightly edited, yet may be laden with inaccurate information. Consider it a base for further inquiry.
Return to New Mexico Art History
Our Distinguished Artists catalogue provides online access to biographical information for artists associated with this state. Also, Search Resource Library for online articles and essays concerning both individual artists associated with this state's history and the history of art centers and museums in this state. Resource Library articles and essays devoted to individual artists and institutions are not listed on this page.
*Tag for expired US copyright of object image:
Links to sources of information outside of our web site are provided only as referrals for your further consideration. Please use due diligence in judging the quality of information contained in these and all other web sites. Information from linked sources may be inaccurate or out of date. TFAO neither recommends or endorses these referenced organizations. Although TFAO includes links to other web sites, it takes no responsibility for the content or information contained on those other sites, nor exerts any editorial or other control over them. For more information on evaluating web pages see TFAO's General Resources section in Online Resources for Collectors and Students of Art History.
Search Resource Library
Copyright 2025 Traditional Fine Arts Organization, Inc., an Arizona nonprofit corporation. All rights reserved.