Editor's note: The National Academy Museum and School of Fine Arts provided source material to Resource Library for the following article or essay. If you have questions or comments regarding the source material, please contact the The National Academy Museum and School of Fine Arts directly through either this phone number or web address:



 

Luminist Horizons: The Art and Collection of James A. Suydam

September 14 - December 31, 2006

 

The first major exhibition in a quarter century to explore luminism in nineteenth-century American landscape painting, Luminist Horizons: The Art and Collection of James A. Suydam, is on exhibit September 14 through December 31, 2006 at the National Academy Museum. The exhibition features approximately fifty-five paintings by Suydam (1819-1865) and the artists of his circle, including John F. Kensett, Asher B. Durand, Frederic Edwin Church, Sanford R. Gifford, Jasper Cropsey, and many others. Suydam's collection, bequeathed in its entirety to the National Academy in 1865, documents the many American and European influences on Suydam and his peers as they explored qualities of light and atmosphere in the landscape. Luminist Horizons reveals the exceptional strength of the artist's collection and presents the first ever retrospective of Suydam's career, including his masterpiece, Paradise Rocks, Newport (1860).

Luminist Horizons contributes a new, individual perspective on the development of luminism in Civil War America. Often characterized by art historians as an aesthetic of solitary isolation, luminism was, instead, a gregarious experience for Suydam and his peers. His first acquisition was a landscape (1850) by Asher B. Durand depicting two artists conversing while admiring the landscape. Accompanied by close friends, such as Kensett, Gifford, and Worthington Whittredge, Suydam visited popular sites during the 1850s and 1860s, particularly in the Hudson River Valley, the Mt. Washington region, and along the Rhode Island coast. He made these iconic sites his own by interpreting their well-known vistas with his unique colorism, crisp geometry, and fresh compositional arrangements.

Suydam was a son of one of New York's early Dutch merchant families. He inherited a considerable fortune early in life that permitted him to tour Europe and the Middle East for several years after he completed his studies at New York University. His career in art began in middle age, as an amateur painter working under the influence of Durand and the instruction of Kensett, whose landmark Bash Bish (1855) Suydam owned.

By the later 1850s, Suydam transformed himself into a professional artist and was elected to full membership in the National Academy of Design in 1861, the same year as the onset of the Civil War. In the midst of national crisis, Suydam and his peers created an art of stability, peace, and order.

Luminist Horizons is co-curated by Mark D. Mitchell, Associate Curator of Nineteenth-Century Art at the National Academy Museum, and Katherine E. Manthorne, Professor of American Art at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York. A full color catalogue by the curators with an introduction by Annette Blaugrund, and published by George Braziller Publishers will accompany the exhibition.

 

PUBLIC PROGRAMS

 

THE REVIEW PANEL
October 6th, November 3rd, December 1st, 6:30PM in the Huntington Library
On the first Friday of every month the National Academy invites contemporary critics to discuss current art exhibitions and debate the ideas, issues, and aesthetics consequently generated. This popular panel is moderated by David Cohen, art critic for the New York Sun and editor of artcritical.com.
 
FAMILY ARTS
October 7th, November 4th, December 1st, 10:00AM - 12:00PM in the Galleries
Families gather for an educator-led gallery talk and an art-making workshop with professional artist Martha Bloom. Fee. Due to limited space reservations are required. Phone 212 369 4880 x 300 or email education@nationalacademy.org.
 
SYMPOSIUM: LUMINISM REVISITED
Saturday, October 28, 2006, 1pm - 6pm in the Huntington Library
This afternoon symposium will feature a panel of leading scholars as they present new research relating to luminism and the social, philosophical, ethical, and scientific ideas of mid-nineteenth century America. Fee.. Reservations required, phone 212 369 4880 x 300 or email education@nationalacademy.org.
 
LUNCHTIME LECTURES ­ The Exhibition Series with
Thursdays, 12 pm - 1 pm in the rotunda of the museum, in the galleries, and in the Huntington Library
November 2, Associate Curator of Nineteenth-Century Art, Mark Mitchell lead visitors through highlighted paintings from Luminist Horizons.
November 16, Associate Curator of Nineteenth-Century Art, Mark Mitchell moderates a panel of professional artists to discuss the importance of luminism on current works.
December 7, Assistant Curator of Modern and Contemporary Art, Marshall Price, leads us through some American artists' representations of the Italian culture and landscape.
 
 

 

(above: Andreas Achenbach, 1815 -1910, German, Off Ostend, 1859, Oil on canvas, 49 ? x 68 inches. National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam)

 

(above: Daniel Huntington, 1816-1906, James Augustus Suydam, NA, 1862, Oil on canvas, 30 x 25 inches. National Academy Museum, bequest of James A. Suydam)

 

(above: Eastman Johnson, 1824-1906, The Art Lover, n.d., Oil on canvas, 12 3/8 x 15 ? inches. National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam)

 

(above: James A. Suydam, N.A. 1819-1865, Beach at Newport, Rhode Island, ca. 1860­1865, Oil on canvas. Collection of Henry and Sharon Martin)

 


WALL TEXT FROM THE EXHIBITION

 
Luminist Horizons
The Art and Collection of James A. Suydam
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865) was an American landscape painter and collector distinguished for his artistic subtlety and intellectual refinement. Well known in his day, Suydam's work as an artist and art advocate began later in life and lasted only a decade before his sudden death at the height of his career. His legacy was ensured, however, his bequest of his expansive collection of ninety-two paintings, including several of his own works, to the National Academy of Design. This exhibition, the first to explore Suydam's career, offers a fresh opportunity to appreciate his contributions to American art.
 
Suydam's art and collection reveal the close relationships among the painters of his circle-known as luminists for their fascination with light and atmosphere-and their many contemporary influences on both sides of the Atlantic. In concert with his most intimate colleagues-including John F. Kensett, N.A. (1816-1872), Asher B. Durand, N.A. (1796-1886), Sanford Gifford, N.A. (1823-1880), and Worthington Whittredge, N.A. (1820-1910)-Suydam developed his signature style, characterized by gentle tonal gradations, abstracted forms, and a limited palette, along the shores of Rhode Island during the early 1860s. His aesthetic, exemplified by his masterpiece, Paradise Rocks, Newport, was admired by contemporaries as "nature in repose."
 
Peace was in short supply during Suydam's career, however. Amid the violence of the American Civil War, the artist and his colleagues sought order and reassurance in the national landscape. Suydam's art and professional ambitions matured during the period as well, culminating in his election as a full National Academician (N.A.) in 1861, the same year as the war's onset. In this context, his paintings not only provide a sense of stability, but also evoke profound sentiment underlying their calm surfaces in response to national events. Ultimately, the exhibition extends the understanding of the luminist painters' horizons to include such broader historic as well as artistic influence.
 
This exhibition is made possible by the generous support of the Henry Luce Foundation, the National Endowment for the Arts, Eli Wilner & Company, the Lucelia Foundation, the Robert Lehman Foundation, The Brown Foundation, Inc., of Houston, Furthermore: a program of the J. M. Kaplan Fund, and the Asher B. Durand Society of the National Academy Museum. Programs of the National Academy are made possible with public funds from the New York State Council on the Arts, a state agency.
 
 
Early Career
 
Suydam began to draw shortly after his graduation from New York University (then known as the University of the City of New York) in 1842 while on a three-year Grand Tour of Europe and the Middle East under the capable guidance of expatriate painter Miner Kellogg, Honorary N.A. (1814-1889). The son of one of New York's oldest Dutch merchant families, Suydam entered a business partnership with his brother upon his return that lasted for nearly a decade. Consequently, his artistic practice did not begin in earnest until the 1850s, when he studied with one of the leading figures of American landscape movement, John F. Kensett, N.A.
 
Suydam's public début at the National Academy's Annual Exhibition of 1856 marked the beginning of his transition from gentleman-amateur to professional artist. His early works are distinguished by their sense of intimacy and variety. Suydam's inherited wealth allowed him more creative freedom than many of his peers, and the diversity of his early compositions illustrates his experimentation with the prevailing conventions of landscape painting.
 
 
Newport
 
The beaches of Newport, Rhode Island offered Suydam enduring inspiration beginning in the late 1850s. Settling on a broad, open format that prioritized poetic effect over narrative, the artist painted in larger scale and exhibited his canvases with greater frequency in New York and around the country. In Suydam's mature work, areas of color interact and balance against one another, evoking rather than recording specific features found in nature.
 
The expressive aspects of these later works may be attributed to the artist's own emotional investment. "I must paint what I feel," he wrote. Suydam's demanding professional commitment to the Academy as treasurer of its Fellowship Fund and ongoing anxiety over the Civil War worsened the recurring depression with which he struggled throughout adulthood. He did, however, find welcome relief in his summertime painting excursions. Through his restricted palette and mannered composition, Suydam manipulated his subjects to exaggerate their most expressive features and thereby cultivate the tranquil, contemplative aspect of his work that was most admired by his contemporaries.
 
 
Artistic Circle
 
In 1858, Suydam moved his workspace to the new Tenth Street Studio Building, located a few blocks from his family's townhouse just off Washington Square. Other Tenth Street artists who moved there at about the same moment included his close friends and fellow landscape painters Frederic Edwin Church, N.A. (1826-1900), Sanford R. Gifford, N.A. (1823-1880), Louis Rémy Mignot, N.A. (1831-1870), and Worthington Whittredge, N.A. (1820-1910). Although Kensett, Suydam's closest colleague, did not take a studio in the building, they were virtually next-door neighbors at home on Waverly Place. All members of the National Academy of Design and the Century Association, a social club, the artists of Suydam's innermost circle lived, worked, relaxed, traveled, and exhibited together, facilitating the close friendships that contributed to their art.
 
Asher B. Durand, N.A. (1796-1886) was in many ways the group's artistic patriarch, serving as a vital inspiration to the group. Durand's Landscape (1850) was among Suydam's earliest purchases and depicts two artists discussing the scene before them, a model of the collaborative artistic discovery enjoyed by Suydam and his peers. An integral member of what he called his "fraternity," Suydam contributed an important philosophical counterbalance to the commercial spirit that permeated the New York art world during the 1860s.
 
 
Beyond Landscape
 
Suydam's collection of American and European genre paintings offers a different perspective on his artistic sensibility. Depictions of women and children were common in the sentimental society of Victorian America, but in the collection of the bachelor Suydam, their frequency suggests particular resonance in his personal life. Similar to the tranquility of the landscapes that he painted, the depictions of women and children in his collection are more the subjects of desire than reality.
 
Reading, a prominent theme in Suydam's genre collection, reflects the significance of books to Suydam's life. After the artist's death, his library was sold at auction and is therefore fully documented. His books portray a rich intellectual life, including interests in English and American literature, fluency in French, and aptitude for music. Most substantive, however, were his collections of art history and philosophy. The concentration of the readers in Suydam's collection conveys the seriousness with which he regarded their activity.
 
 
Luminism
 
The term "luminism" has undergone almost constant revision since it was coined by art historian John I. H. Baur during the late 1940s. Suydam was a central figure in Baur's initial definition of the term to describe the work of a group of then little-known American landscape painters who shared a distinctive attitude toward light and nature itself. Subsequent studies have explored and debated its correlation with contemporary religious and philosophical movements, primarily transcendentalism because of its focus on the divine presence in the landscape. Although luminism is not a term that was used in the artists' day, it concisely describes the qualities of light, atmosphere, and poetic evocation that characterize Suydam's work as well as that of his closest peers.
 
Suydam's art and collection make clear that, for him, luminism was an aesthetic based in shared experience and mutual influence, though not conformity. The works in this gallery depict many of the sites that the artists visited and highlight the variety of their approaches. These paintings constitute the core of Suydam's collection, including several masterpieces of American art, and provide the artist's own unique perspective on the aesthetic of luminism through his choices as an artist as well as a collector.
 
 
Conflict and Context
 
Suydam and his colleagues worked against a backdrop of violence. During the 1850s and early 1860s, the prelude to and onset of the Civil War created uncertainty about the nation's future. Suydam's letters and collection document his sympathy with the Union and abolition, but the course of the war itself caused the artist great concern and occupied his thoughts as he closely followed national events in the press. His sudden death just months after the end of the war offered fitting closure for an artistic career that so uncannily paralleled national events.
 
Conflict is both a subtext of Suydam's art and a significant theme in his collection, most prominently illustrated by the monumental Off Ostend by German painter Andreas Achenbach (1815-1910). The romantic, expressive drama of the storm scenes in Suydam's collection, including an unusual work by Jasper Cropsey, N.A. (1823-1900), enrich the appreciation of his own work by drawing attention to their emotive aspect. Though emotion similarly animates Suydam's own paintings, he more often phrased moods in the tenor of the escapist portrayals of the sunny Italian countryside that he owned by artists such as Albert Flamm (1823-1906) and Thomas Hicks, N.A. (1823-1890), which doubtless reminded him of his own youthful travels in simpler times.
 


OBJECT LABELS FROM THE EXHIBITION

 
Andreas Achenbach (1815-1910)
Off Ostend
1859
Oil on canvas
 
Inspired by the grand sky effects of the seventeenth-century Dutch masters, German realist Andreas Achenbach's powerful seascapes were derived from sketches that he made on site. Achenbach's prominence in the art community of Düsseldorf attracted the attention and emulation of many aspiring landscape painters. Exhibited in New York in 1860­1861 when Suydam likely saw and purchased the work, Off Ostend depicts the struggle for survival of a Belgian fishing community on the North Sea.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam

 
George Henry Boughton, N.A. (1833-1905)
Wandering Thoughts
1865
Oil on canvas
 
This painting was among the first of expatriate George Henry Boughton's genre scenes depicting American colonial life-the subject for which he would become best known-and among last that Suydam acquired before his death. This portrayal of a chaste young Puritan contemplating a flower is made more haunting by the ghostly contours of other figures around her that the artist appears to have painted out, but whose presence in the woman's thoughts is suggested by the cut flower's short-lived beauty. Painted at the conclusion of the Civil War, Wandering Thoughts reflects wistfully on a simpler time in American history.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
George Henry Boughton, N.A. (1833-1905)
Winter Scene
1860
Oil on canvas
 
Known primarily as a painter of figures, George Henry Boughton got his start in New York as a landscapist. Winter Scene is one of a handful of winter scenes he executed that demonstrate his abilities to blend frozen streams, snow-covered ground, and frosty atmosphere into a nuanced tonal composition. Boughton later had a highly successful career both in England and America, but at this still early stage he received needed patronage and encouragement from Suydam.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
John George Brown, N.A. (1831-1913)
The Victim
1861
Oil on canvas
 
This painting depicts a characteristic subject by J. G. Brown, who specialized in newspaper boys, bootblacks, and ruffians. Here, a group of snowball-wielding pranksters has ambushed their prey, a diligent errand boy with his basket.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Benjamin Champney (1817-1907)
Conway Valley
1855­57
Oil on canvas
 
Conway Valley depicts a favorite spot in the White Mountains of New Hampshire, where the New York landscape painters frequently spent their summers hiking and sketching. Sometimes dubbed the leader of the White Mountain School for his devotion to the area, Benjamin Champney has evoked all that he, Suydam, and their circle appreciated about the place. The three figures sitting in the foreground harmoniously commune with one another and with nature.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Frederic Edwin Church, N.A. (1826-1900)
Scene among the Andes
1854
Oil on canvas
 
One of two Colombian scenes that Suydam purchased directly from Frederic Edwin Church after Church's first trip to South America in the summer of 1853, Scene among the Andes is among the first compositions that Church painted after his trip. The gentle tonal gradation and colorism of Scene among the Andes parallel the primary aspects of Suydam's own work in the ensuing years, though not Church's own direction. Scene among the Andes offers a pastoral, peaceful counterpoint to the more ominous tenor of the second work that Suydam purchased from Church, his Scene on the Magdalene. The prominence of the century plant (amaryllis) in the foreground, reaching up and out to overlap the river in the distance, is believed to be a discrete allusion to the Century Association, of which Suydam and Church were both members.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Frederic Edwin Church, N.A. (1826-1900)
Scene on the Magdalene
1854
Oil on canvas
 
Frederic Edwin Church's portrayals of the South American landscape often layer beauty and danger, and never more effectively than in his Scene on the Magdalena. The brilliant sunlight at the horizon bathes the sky and serene, reflective water in rich color, but casts deep shadows along the Colombian river Magdalena's banks. At its brightest point in the water, the reflected sun silhouettes the sloping contour of a crocodile moving toward the unsuspecting spear-fishers at the lower right. In the foliage behind them, a similar struggle unfolds as choking vines envelope the trees above. In a pencil sketch related to this scene, Church noted "trees entirely smothered in vines." Such mortal struggles in nature fascinated the young Church, and resonated with audiences in America where the threat of violence and civil war constantly lurked throughout the later 1840s and 1850s.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Jasper Cropsey, N.A. (1823-1900)
Coast Scene
1855
Oil on canvas
 
Jasper Cropsey is best known for his idyllic scenes of brilliant autumn foliage and pastoral New England life. Coast Scene, in contrast, depicts a tumultuous seascape off what is believed to be Newport, Rhode Island. "In its grandest moods," Cropsey wrote in his 1855 essay "Up Among the Clouds," the storm cloud is "more impressive than all the other cloud regions-awakening the deepest emotions of gloom, dread, and fear; or sending thrilling sensations of joy and gladness through our being."
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Jasper Cropsey, N.A. (1823-1900)
The Lake of Nemi
1848
Oil on paper
 
Located southeast of Rome in the Alban Hills, the picturesque Lake of Nemi offered the young, newly-married Jasper Cropsey an impressive, time-honored vantage on the Italian countryside. This painting is a reduced version-probably a study, as suggested by the artist's notes inscribed in the upper right-of a larger composition that is now unlocated. Suydam likely purchased the work in a set of seven studies that he bought directly from Cropsey in 1856 when Cropsey was financing his second trip abroad. Cropsey and Suydam shared much in common, including their Dutch and Huguenot ancestries and their early studies of architecture.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
William P. W. Dana, N.A. (1833-1927)
Admirals in Embryo
undated
Oil on linen
 
Trained in France, William P. W. Dana was praised in America upon his return for "a refinement of taste" that was "rare among our artists." This rendering of young boys playing in a beached boat combines Dana's interest in marine painting with his affectionate renderings of childhood. Here, the boys' play parallels the activities of men on the sea in the distance, but the boys' wreck is inscribed in French "VAU[T] RIEN," meaning worth nothing.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Albert Flamm (1823-1906)
The Roman Campagna
1859
Oil on canvas
 
German painter Albert Flamm was a prominent student of Andreas Achenbach and later an instructor at the academy in Düsseldorf. His treatments of the Italian countryside during the 1850s favored bright sunlight and open expanses often portrayed by Suydam and his American colleagues. Within Suydam's collection, Flamm's work suggests a pendant in both scale and ambition to Achenbach's massive Off Ostend of the same year, and which Suydam likely purchased at the same auction in 1861. The opposition in tone between these two works of similar scale reflects a recurring theme of paired opposites in Suydam's collection, including the two works by Jasper Cropsey included here.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Édouard Frère (1819-1886)
Finishing the Meal
ca. 1855
Oil on panel
 
French genre painter Édouard Frère was enormously popular in America as a painter of poor waifs and kitchen scenes. The presence of what were considered the finer specimens of Frère's work in Suydam's collection allowed the artists in his circle to study and emulate them. Frère's strongest influence was on the Americans' handling of color, painterly touch, and suggestion of narrative.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Sanford R. Gifford, N.A. (1823-1880)
Mount Mansfield, Vermont
1859
Oil on canvas
 
Sanford Gifford was one of Suydam's closest friends and was traveling with him New Hampshire when Suydam fell ill and died in September 1865. Mt. Mansfield was typical of the sites among the Green and White Mountains that the artists frequented during their summer travels. In this depiction of the site, one of nearly twenty that Gifford created after a visit in the summer of 1858, the artist has turned our gaze away from the sun and toward the uneven contours of the mountains. Instead of the tourists who flocked to the area and its new hotels, Gifford has also returned us to an imagined moment in history when Native Americans still lived in the area. Often cited as a quintessential example of luminist aesthetics because of the richness of its hazy atmosphere, Mt. Mansfield also draws attention to the shared traits of asymmetry and heightened color that characterize both Gifford's and Suydam's works.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
William Hart, N.A. (1823-1894)
Twilight
ca. 1860
Oil on canvas
 
A fellow tenant of the Tenth Street Studio Building with Suydam and other members of their circle, William Hart helped to codify their shared aesthetic principles in a series of lectures delivered at the Brooklyn Academy of Design in 1865. Entitled The Field and the Easel, Hart's lectures described their art as a balance between documents of specific sites and embodiments of poetic sentiment. Twilight offers an example of this balanced approach, depicting the outskirts of a village during the ebbing moments of daylight as the campfire at left and homefire at right match the sunset in color and warmth.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Thomas Hicks, N.A. (1823-1890)
The Home Guard
1863
Oil on canvas
 
This seemingly satirical painting by Thomas Hicks is the only direct representation of the Civil War in Suydam's extensive collection. Notable for its sense of irony, the work shows a Union soldier occupied holding yarn as he woos a young woman under the contemptuous watch of her chaperone, rather than engaged in the service of his country. Moreover, the soldier is no symbol of virility, with his balding head and slender limbs. Suydam and Hicks were both pro-Union abolitionists, however, evidenced by Suydam's ownership of Hicks' portrait of Harriet Beecher Stowe, and the work is therefore more likely a veiled indictment of the Union's poor management of its manpower than a critique of the soldiers themselves.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Thomas Hicks, N.A. (1823-1890)
Italian Study
ca. 1847­48
Oil on paper mounted on composition board
 
Thomas Hicks completed this rare landscape, unusual because Hicks was predominantly a portraitist, while traveling through Europe as a student. This romantic rendering of Italy's scenic ruins must have reminded Suydam of his own creative efforts while on the Grand Tour earlier in the decade and of the appeal that such sites of antiquity held for him.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Daniel Huntington, N.A. (1816-1906)
The Fair Student
1858
Oil on canvas
 
This depiction of a young woman reading was painted by Daniel Huntington while the artist was visiting London. The subject reflects a common theme in Huntington's work: the transmission of learning between generations. The figure's dress, the decorative objects in the room, and the Baroque style of the patriarchal portrait on the wall collectively suggest that Huntington's work is intended to be a period piece. Suydam apparently preferred the present, somewhat subjective title for the work over the more descriptive one that Huntington originally used to describe it in his account book, Girl Reading.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Daniel Huntington, N.A. (1816-1906)
James Augustus Suydam, N.A.
1862
Oil on canvas
 
Daniel Huntington's portrait of Suydam was created at the height of Suydam's professional career and shortly after Suydam's elected as a full National Academician (N.A.), a designation that is proudly incorporated into the painting's title. Suydam is depicted not against a peaceful, luminous coast such as those that he often depicted in his own work, but rather an overcast, stormy seascape. Suydam's distant expression combined with the turbulent backdrop manifest both his preoccupation with the events of the Civil War and the persistent depression that plagued him in adulthood.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Daniel Huntington, N.A. (1816-1906)
Glimpses from the Forest
1856
Oil on canvas
 
Originally listed in Daniel Huntington's account book as A Look out from the Woods, this painting demonstrates the artist's early interest in landscape painting, which he would largely abandon during the later 1850s for a distinguished career in portraiture. Such pristine forest was increasingly rare in the northeast during mid-century as Americans' voracious need for lumber, farmland, and pastures rapidly stripped the area of its old-growth trees. Huntington's landscape, like his genre paintings in Suydam's collection, depicts a bygone moment in America, rather than the treeless shorelines of Suydam's own contemporary views.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Eastman Johnson, N.A. (1824-1906)
The Art Lover
1859
Oil on canvas
 
Based on a drawing that he made while living and working in The Hague during the early 1850s, Eastman Johnson's The Art Lover depicts a Dutch girl's aesthetic education from a book of landscape prints. Suydam's purchase of Johnson's painting after what is believed to be its first exhibition in 1859 illustrates Suydam's interest in Dutch culture and his own Dutch heritage. The subject's introspection and the composition's rich contrasts of light and dark are aspects of the Dutch visual tradition that influenced both Johnson and Suydam.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Miner Kellogg, H.N.A. (1814-1889)
Circassian Girl
undated
Oil on panel
 
Circassian women became the subject of considerable fascination among Americans during the mid-nineteenth century. Considered the ideal Caucasian type, historically found in what is today southwestern Russia, their legendary beauty was famously exploited after Russian conquest of their homeland during mid-century forced them to flee into neighboring Turkey. Kellogg's familiarity with the Near East, illustrated here by the Circassian Girl, encouraged Suydam to include the region on his extended Grand Tour during the early 1840s.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
John F. Kensett, N.A. (1816-1872)
Approaching Shower
1859
Oil on canvas
 
Similar in tone to much of Suydam's work, John F. Kensett's Approaching Shower provides a sense of pastoral balance with nature. A man leads his herd of cattle home ahead of the coming rain, which itself offers an opportune excuse to illustrate the effects of rain on the atmosphere. The restful tenor of this painting is interrupted only by the dead branch of a tree at the lower right that foretells the snaking form of a lightning strike.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
John F. Kensett, N.A. (1816-1872)
Bash Bish
1855
Oil on canvas
 
Bash Bish is widely recognized as one of John F. Kensett's masterworks. The painting depicts a popular waterfall in the Berkshire Mountains of western Massachusetts, near Stockbridge, that was admired as "one of the wildest and most beautiful cascades in the country," according to a writer for The Crayon in 1855. Kensett depicted the site repeatedly during the 1850s, altering the scale, format, vantage point, and effects in each. This version, painted on commission from Suydam, and is the largest of the series and thrusts the viewer out into the open water of the pool at the waterfall's base while creating a symmetrical balance of the cliffs on either side of the falls. In contrast to the majestic, overwhelming power of Niagara, Bash Bish Falls provides a more subtle and restrained subject with its almost three-hundred-foot cliffs skewed to a more human scale. The fact that this, one of Kensett's most ambitious compositions, was painted on commission from his student, Suydam, reveals the complexity of their evolving relationship.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
John F. Kensett, N.A. (1816-1872)
Glimpse through the Wood
undated
Oil on canvas
 
This modest forest interior differs dramatically in kind from the other forest interior by John F. Kensett in Suydam's collection, his large-scale Bash Bish. This more intimate scene conveys the feeling of intimacy that characterized Suydam's own early work during the 1850s. Kensett often painted in small scale, providing an important model for Suydam's early oil paintings.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
John F. Kensett, N.A. (1816-1872)
On the Narragansett Coast
1864
Oil on canvas
 
The close interaction of Suydam and John F. Kensett as colleagues during the later phase of Suydam's career is documented by this painting. In their shared subject, degree of abstraction, compositional arrangement, saturated color, tonal gradation in the sky, and contemplative mood, the two artists worked closely toward similar ends. Their poetic landscapes of Narragansett Bay during the 1860s provide important evidence of their collective effort and mutual influence.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
John F. Kensett, N.A. (1816-1872)
Study from Nature
undated
Oil on canvas
 
This somewhat uncharacteristic scene by Kensett offers a composite of elements of his better-known subjects of forest interiors and mountain valleys. Likely a depiction of New Hampshire or Vermont, Kensett has balanced the carefully rendered birches and rock at the right with the more atmospheric form of the mountain at the left. That balance of specific detail with atmospheric effect is a recurring trait of luminist painting.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
George Cochran Lambdin, N.A. (1830-1896)
Drawing the Elephant
1859
Oil on canvas
 
Among the scenes of childhood that Suydam acquired, the theme of nurturing art talent in the young takes on special importance. Here we see the work of a realist painter acted out in miniature: one child holds up a toy elephant while the young artist stares intently at the model as she draws, and the youngest looks on in admiration. This is one of Lambdin's finer genre scenes and it features in the background a vase of roses, which became his specialty after the Civil War.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Louis Lang, N.A. (1814-1893)
The Fainting Spell
1860
Oil on canvas
 
Suydam may have been John F. Kensett's closest professional colleague, but Kensett's dearest friend was undoubtedly genre painter Louis Lang, with whom he shared rooms at their boardinghouse. Lang's depiction of a listless young woman in this composition adopts the popular Victorian theme of feminine vulnerability and underscores the sentimentalism found in Suydam's genre painting collection.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Evariste Vital Luminais (1822-1896)
Pull Up the Hill
1858
Oil on canvas
 
This work was created well before French painter Evariste Vital Luminais gained his august reputation as a master artist, and undoubtedly appealed to Suydam for its evocation of youthful enjoyment rather than the fame of its maker. Pull Up the Hill depicts a group of boys dragging, wrestling, and pushing a cart and its girl driver up a steep path, striking a note of sweet innocence and youthful chivalry.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Louis Rémy Mignot, N.A. (1831-1870)
Sources of the Susquehanna
1857
Oil on canvas
 
Louis Rémy Mignot was a southern-born painter who departed for South America with Frederic Edwin Church shortly after this work was completed. Taking as its subject the headwaters of the Susquehanna River on the western slope of the Caskill Mountains, Mignot's painting partook of the taste for national landscapes during the 1850s. The nuanced palette of greens in the vegetation and the subtle twilight of the sky belie Suydam's own limited palette and poetic use of color.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Jules Achille Noël (1815-1881)
Coast Scene
1857
Oil on canvas
 
Although tourism played a significant role in turning American artists' attention to the ocean and beaches, so too did the influence of European artists in Suydam's collection, such as French painter Jules Achille Noël. The wave-pounded coast of here suggests another dimension of man's interaction with the sea from the contemplative one most often portrayed by Suydam and his colleagues.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
William Trost Richards, N.A. (1833-1905)
Landscape
1862
Oil on cardboard
 
Better known for finely-detailed landscape compositions that are more closely aligned with the principles of British critic John Ruskin, a champion of meticulous realism, William Trost Richards' early Landscape bears the hallmarks of a luminist composition with its rich sunlight, expansive horizon, open sky, and gentle gradation of color. Suydam's ownership of this composition may derive from the fact that it is so atypical for Richards, yet akin to Suydam's taste.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Paul Seignac (1826-1904)
The Young Cook
undated
Oil on panel
 
French painter Paul Seignac painted in the realist tradition and specialized in domestic interiors with children in the roles of adults. Contemporaries particularly appreciated his lighting effects and soft colors, which lent particular charm to his depictions of working-class life in the manner of Édouard Frère (1819-1886) and Théophile Emmanuel Duverger (1821­ca. 1901), whose works are also represented in Suydam's collection.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Aaron Draper Shattuck, N.A. (1832-1928)
Along the Saco
1857
Oil on canvas
 
This compact scene is notable for its resemblance to Suydam's small-scale works of the 1850s. The lyrical, gem-like idyll invites admiration not of the grandeur of the White Mountains in New Hampshire seen in the distance, but rather of the quiet intimacy of the peaceful river and its gently-sloping bank.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam

Aaron Draper Shattuck, N.A. (1832-1928)
On the Saco, North Conway
undated
Oil on canvas
 
John I. H. Baur, the scholar who single-handedly rediscovered Suydam's works in 1950, initially attributed this painting by Aaron Draper Shattuck to Suydam. Although that attribution has since been reversed, the sympathy between the techniques of the two painters remains clear. Though over a decade Suydam's junior, Shattuck began exhibiting his White Mountain subjects at the National Academy's Annual Exhibitions at the same time that Suydam did, and the two were aligned in the eyes of one critic as part of a group of "young and little-known men" who showed great promise as landscape painters during the mid-1850s. Whereas Suydam moved decisively to the coast for subject matter around 1860, however, Shattuck continued to make the White Mountains his primary destination, permanently associating him with the region in the minds of collectors and critics alike.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
 
Aaron Draper Shattuck, N.A. (1832-1928)
The Ford
1856
Oil on canvas
 
When this painting, one of three by Aaron Draper Shattuck in Suydam's collection that depict North Conway, New Hampshire, was first exhibited at the National Academy of Design's Annual in 1856, one critic remarked that although the painting was "replete with picturesque feeling" it was "a little too facilely executed for a young man, who should spend his energy in trying to do things well rather than easily." The painting shows a comparable degree of asymmetry to Suydam's early Conway Meadows that may indicate mutual awareness at this formative stage of both artists' careers.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
Worthington Whittredge, N.A. (1820-1910)
Study from Nature
1863
Oil on canvas
 
Worthington Whittredge was Suydam's close friend, travel companion, and neighbor in the Tenth Street Studio Building during the 1860s, but this is inexplicably the only one of his paintings in Suydam's collection. Whittredge's Study from Nature is a small-scale work in a series of forest interiors that he created during the early 1860s in the Hudson River Valley. He later recalled the subject of these works as "the primitive woods with their solemn silence reigning everywhere."
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
At River's Bend
ca. 1855
Oil on canvas laid down on artist's board
Private collection

This river scene incorporates several elements that became more prominent in Suydam's mature work, including gentle tonal gradation in the sky that is mirrored in the water, an arcing shoreline at low tide, and figures reduced beyond scale. The painting's size, likely meant for the artist himself rather than the market, encourages close-up study.
 
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Battery Park, New York
undated
Oil on canvas
 
This work is believed to depict the southern tip of New York City, with its active commercial traffic of ships visible in the distance. The dark silhouettes of the sinuous tree trunks in the composition's foreground contrast with the more tightly-rendered masts and rigging of the ships anchored beyond. This uncharacteristic work illustrates Suydam's early experimentation with technique, but its overriding interest in the scene's unique effect of light is entirely consistent with his artistic sensibility.
 
Collection of Howard and Melinda Godel

James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Beach at Newport, Rhode Island
ca. 1860-1865
Oil on canvas
 
Among the most eloquent of Suydam's mature works, this coast scene demonstrates his practice of distilling nature rather than recording it. The vibrant blue triangle of water appears too saturated to be realistic, immediately heightening the composition's overall affect. Similarly, the sunlight bleaches the exposed sand at low tide almost to white. These abutting triangles of blue and white contrast with the more gentle gradation between the same colors in the sky. Suydam likely developed his clean, orderly landscape aesthetic in reaction to the violence and unruliness of the Civil War that raged during this same moment.
 
Collection of Henry and Sharon Martin

James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Beach Scene, Newport
1860
Oil on canvas
 
The fog portrayed in this work creates a ghostly effect, almost obscuring a figure walking along the water and a sailboat in the distance. According to contemporary sources, the daily fogs of Newport had a cleansing effect on the atmosphere that enhanced its healthful climate for urban visitors such as Suydam. The leaden water and darkened sky shown here, however, suggest a more introspective, foreboding interpretation.
 
Private collection

James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Beacon Rock and the Entrance to Newport Harbor
ca. 1860
Oil on canvas
 
Among the most abstract of Suydam's paintings, this work transforms the embankments around Newport's Fort Adams into strict, green trapezoids and the opposing Beacon Rock into a mound of color. The artist's deliberate simplification of form differs fundamentally from his mentor John F. Kensett's approach to recording natural detail in similar rock studies. For Suydam, color, form, and poetic feeling were paramount, and this painting deliberately simplifies the landscape features in a manner reminiscent of folk art rather than academic style.
 
Private collection, courtesy of William Vareika Fine Arts, Newport, R.I.

James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Beverly Rocks
ca. 1860
Oil on canvas
 
National Academy Museum, N.A. Diploma Presentation
Replica frame, ca. 1860s, on loan from Eli Wilner & Company, Inc., New York
When Suydam was elected to full membership in the National Academy of Design in May 1861, he donated this painting to the Academy to represent his work. This view along the coast in Beverly, Massachusetts relates to John F. Kensett's depictions of the same area and illustrates their close working relationship. Suydam's composition, however, differs from Kensett's approach in its richly layered use of color to evoke the filtered light of a morning fog.
 
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Conway Meadows
ca. 1857
Oil on canvas
 
This depiction of one of New Hampshire's best-known sites is notable for its turn away from the grand vista of Mt. Washington itself. (A more conventional perspective is found in Suydam's View of Mt. Washington from the Conway Meadows, hanging nearby.) The view shown here has no single focal point, and instead obscures the distant horizon with scattered autumn trees along the foreground stream's bank. Suydam's composition seems contrived to flout conventional notions of the picturesque and highlights a key aspect of his mature work: asymmetry.
 
Private collection, courtesy of Brock & Co., Carlisle, Mass.

James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
The Fisherman
1848
Graphite, pen and ink, and transparent watercolor on wove paper
 
Suydam's earliest work by at least seven years, this light-hearted figure drawing is inscribed "A hearty man a fishing went / And on a chub his looks he bent." This is the artist's only known figure drawing, but it shows a competency that is remarkable so early in his career. The intimacy of the drawing is characteristic of much of Suydam's early work as an amateur artist.
 
Lent by Mr. and Mrs. Stuart P. Feld
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Hook Mountain, Hudson River
1863
Oil on canvas
 
This idyllic scene constitutes one of the fullest realizations of Suydam's shoreline aesthetic during the 1860s. River scenes engaged the artist's attention throughout his career, but here the composition contains a more detailed foreground, varied palette, nuanced tonal gradation across the sky, and subtle atmosphere that veils the distant mountain. The work has recently been re-identified as a view along the Hudson River, based on the discovery of the painting's vantage point, which aligns it with the tradition begun by Thomas Cole, N.A. (1801-1848), founder of the Hudson River School.
 
Ann and Lee Higdon
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Long Island
1862
Oil on canvas
 
This vibrant sunset is among Suydam's most vivid, dramatic compositions. The ripples of water in the foreground captivated the artist as much as the sky, and he approached them with a degree of active brushwork that is unique in his oeuvre. The rustic fence high on the embankment prevents cattle from wandering into the dangerous quagmire, a potent symbol for a nation in the midst of Civil War.
 
Collection of Mary Ann and Jack Hollihan
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Moonlit Scene
undated
Oil on canvas
 
This rare nocturne by Suydam is remarkable for its expressiveness. A lone figure, barely visible, stands on the spit of land in the middle ground, silhouetted by the moonlight. The buildings of the village at the right are loosely-rendered with few distinctive features other than gabled roofs that do not distract attention from the overall effect. Suydam's technique of using only a few colors at a time lends itself well to the relative darkness of a night under the full moon.
 
Private collection
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Newport, Hanging Rock
ca. 1860
Oil on canvas
 
This is the smaller of two versions of Suydam's best known scene, Paradise Rocks in Newport, Rhode Island, sometimes also referred to as Hanging Rock or Berkeley's Seat. This version is likely a study for the larger painting in the Academy's collection, on view in another gallery. The active brushwork, brilliancy of effect, and thinness of paint collectively convey a sense of fresh observation that differs from Suydam's final composition with its elevated level of abstraction from nature.
 
Private collection, New York
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Ocean Beach
undated
Oil on canvas
 
This painting illustrates Suydam's work at its most minimal. A whiplash arc of beach stretches from the lower right corner of the foreground nearly to the left edge before returning to the right edge again at the horizon. Despite its elevated vantage point, this panoramic scene reduces the distant landscape to a narrow wedge so that the composition has only three major elements: sea, sand, and sky. Suydam miniaturized the figures walking along the beach and reduced the waves to little more than white ripples. Ocean Beach shows Suydam's interest in abstracted landscape at its extreme.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
Replica frame, ca. 1860s, on loan from Eli Wilner & Company, Inc., New York
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Paradise Rocks, Newport
1860
Oil on canvas
 
This painting represents the culmination of Suydam's artistic achievement. Uniting his interests in poetic abstraction from nature, colorism, and tranquil order, Paradise Rocks, Newport was itself influential, defining an iconic American view that was emulated by the artists of Suydam's circle long after his death. The painting is equally a symbol of Suydam's familiarity with the site where early theologian and philosopher George Berkeley (1685-1753) often worked during his extended stay in colonial Rhode Island. It was here that Berkeley formulated his influential theories of the nature of vision that prevailed until Suydam's day. Suydam challenged Berkeley's approach to art, however, by emphasizing light and color rather than space as Berkeley championed.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
 
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
River Landscape
undated
Oil on canvas
 
This early river scene invokes the romantic tradition of early Hudson River School painting that remained influential in Suydam's day. The broken stump at the lower left and the adjacent rotting log emphasize the pattern of death and renewal in nature that was a major theme in early American landscape painting. Rays of sunlight cascading through the clouds also suggest the reassuring presence of divine order. This work is an unusually direct engagement with the romantic tradition best exemplified by the works of Jasper Cropsey, N.A. (1823-1900) in Suydam's own generation.
 
Richard J. and Beatta K. Simmons and William R. and Kristie L. Berger
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Salt Meadow, Long Island
undated
Oil on canvas
 
Suydam spent much of his career painting scenes of the tidal zones of the American northeast, not all of them beaches. Salt Meadow, Long Island portrays one of these constantly changing coastal areas. The open expanse of meadow offers a plane across which the intermittent sunlight plays as it passes through the clouds.
 
Anonymous loan, courtesy of Paul Worman
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Twilight
undated
Oil on canvas
National Academy Museum
 
This work is an exquisite illustration of Suydam's mastery of tonal gradation. The silhouetted windmill in the foreground symbolizes the early evening's perfect stillness. Its sharply delineated form gives no sense of movement. In the waning sunlight, the emerging moon is a barely visible sliver in the bright orange sky.
 
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
Twilight, Salt Lake, Narragansett
ca. 1858
Oil on canvas
 
Among the first works that Suydam painted of Rhode Island, Twilight, Salt Lake, Narragansett demonstrates his early interest in the unique qualities of light and atmosphere in the area that led him to return year after year. The rich hues of twilight are echoed in the water, creating the sense of an overall composition of color, rather than an experience of place.
 
Century Association, New York, Edward Slosson Bequest, 1871
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
View of Mt. Washington from the Conway Meadows
ca. 1860
Oil on canvas
 
This depiction of Mt. Washington adopts the classic view that John F. Kensett made famous in 1851. Suydam's painting, however, shifts attention away from the harmonious balance of man and nature that was Kensett's theme toward the massive, overlapping planes of color created by the mountainsides. His firm contours set the mountains off from one another, and the misty atmosphere between the peaks provides a sense of their recession into space. The sky and meadow are similarly idealized, effectively producing a color study more than a descriptive record of this venerated landmark.
 
Collection of Dr. Michel and Victoria Hersen
 
 
James A. Suydam, N.A. (1819-1865)
The Windmill, Easthampton, Long Island
ca. 1864
Oil on canvas
Century Association, New York, William Cullen Bryant Collection
 
Windmills make frequent appearances in Suydam's landscapes, most often in the distance or in silhouette. In this work, however, which Suydam gave to the poet William Cullen Bryant in honor of his seventieth birthday, the windmill is featured. Windmills are somewhat rare subjects in American art, but Suydam sought them out, taking inspiration from the Dutch landscape painting tradition and honoring his own Dutch heritage.
 
 
Replica frame, ca. 1860s, on loan from Eli Wilner & Company, Inc., New York
 
 
Replica frame, ca. 1860s, on loan from Eli Wilner & Company, Inc., New York
 
 
Replica frame, ca. 1860s, on loan from Eli Wilner & Company, Inc., New York
 
 
Asher B. Durand, N.A. (1796-1886)
Landscape
1850
Oil on canvas
 
This work by the "dean" of Hudson River School painting, Asher B. Durand, illustrates the important influence that he exerted on Suydam and his contemporaries. Durand enjoyed virtually undisputed preeminence in American art during mid-century and became an important mentor for the generation of American landscapists who followed in the path blazed by Thomas Cole, N.A. (1801-1848) from 1825 until his early death. Durand's Landscape, painted just two years after Cole's death, depicts two artists resting amid a scene that strongly suggests an idealized version of the landscape of the upper Hudson looking south to the Catskill Mountains.
 
National Academy Museum, Bequest of James A. Suydam
Replica frame, ca. 1850s, on loan from Eli Wilner & Company, Inc., New York
 
Frames
 
The artists of Suydam's circle gave great care to the selection of frames for their works, recognizing their importance to the successful presentation of their art. Because the works came directly to the Academy from Suydam's estate, many of the paintings retain their original frames. Several major examples are on view in this gallery, including the elaborately molded frames on John F. Kensett's Bash Bish and Frederic Edwin Church's Scene on the Magdalene.
 
Eli Wilner & Company, Inc. has generously supported the restoration of twelve of these original frames, among other contributions to the exhibition.


Editor's note: RL readers may also enjoy:

 

Read more articles and essays concerning this institutional source by visiting the sub-index page for the National Academy Museum in Resource Library.


Visit the Table of Contents for Resource Library for thousands of articles and essays on American art.

Copyright 2005 Traditional Fine Arts Organization, Inc., an Arizona nonprofit corporation. All rights reserved.